A Quick & Cheap Deer Fence

Our beans just starting to
germinate -- we needed a fence!

As more and more of our neighbors find out about our plans for our garden, the one thing we've heard over and over is that we're wasting our time because “there's waaaaaaaay more deer now than there used to be."  A lot of folks have had such bad luck with deer eating everything that they've given up on gardening altogether.  We hope this isn't in the cards for us, but we do want to protect our investments (of time, money, and future food!), so we just installed a deer fence that we hope will suffice.

The general rule on deer fencing is that you either need a barrier that's electric, one tall enough that they can't jump over (8' minimum), or a double layer of fencing that confuses the deer's poor sense of depth perception so it won't jump over a shorter run.  Due to owning some leftover 8' tall deer netting, we decided to go for the barrier based on height.

Installing a deer fence June 2011 back in DC

Last time the two of us worked on installing a deer fence was at a 1.5 acre community garden in DC.  That was a project done on back-to-back 90-degree, 90-percent-humidity days common to June in DC, working 11 hours of hard labor each day, all weekend long.  It took a grant and a lot of fundraising to cover the materials cost of $5,300 and it took over 350 person-hours of volunteer work to bring that deer fence installation project to completion!  (Side note: this original deer fence installation happened the weekend immediately preceding the marathon back-to-back 13-hour labor-intensive days deconstructing our Hoophouse 1.0, culminating in a visit to the ER for Chris and the unrelated but simultaneously received announcement of Bea's parents getting divorced after 30+ years -- leading June 2011 to be permanently emblazoned in our minds as the “Month from Hell".)

So when Bea said those two words “deer fence", it was received sort of like some curse words that conjured up a whole host of bad memories promised never to be repeated.  But Bea assured Chris the deer fence this time would be relatively painless, and we got started looking for some 8'+ tall posts.

Since we couldn't find enough materials quite tall enough lying around our house, and we didn't want to spend much if any money on this project, we went on our first trip to Charlottesville's Habitat ReStore -- very similar concept to where we used to work at Community Forklift.  Unfortunately for us, this ReStore had a WHOLE LEVEL of awesome furnishings but very little in the way of lumber, and no scrap metal or pipes like we'd thought we might be able to use for this project.  Bea did manage to find two 4-packs of 8' 2x2s standing upright in the corner between two sets of stair treads, about the only lumber in the whole warehouse.  Of course she also got side-tracked by the amazing deal on pepper plants ($2 for 4-packs!) and was able to find replacements for most of our pepper varieties that never germinated.  We left calling the visit a win!

Anyway, we picked up the packs of posts for $3 each and bought some 2" ID (inner diameter) pipes at Lowes.  We got both metal (2-3/8" OD chainlink gate posts) and plastic (2" PVC) since we weren't sure about how pounding the PVC into hard clay would work, but it seems to have worked successfully so we can now return the metal chainlink pipes for our money back -- phew! They were expensive!

Taking breaks is crucial!

We cut the PVC into 30" sections and used a PVC cap set on top to pound on with a sledge hammer (to prevent the pipe itself from shattering from the impact).  We'd recommend buying the next-up size of cap so you don't have to work so hard to pry it off each time!  Or use a piece of wood to absorb the force, which is what we ended up doing after the cap split into pieces.  Pound the pipes into the ground halfway (15").  Then set a 2x2 upright in each pipe (square peg in a round hole, but it fits!).  We spaced the pipes/posts at 10' apart all around the perimeter of our garden.

For our corners, Bea found these 5-gallon buckets of concrete that she'd stuck 4x4s in ages ago in a half-witted scheme of making a DIY hammock stand.  (Of course we moved these here “just in case they're useful some day"!).  In any case, they were the perfect sturdy corner posts; we had to dig out a hole the size of a 5-gallon bucket instead of just digging out the size of a 4x4 and adding a post plus concrete like we would've done if we hadn't already had these bucket-posts lying around.


We had only found a total of 8 2x2s at the ReStore, so while we could've bought more at Lowes, we also saw that we had a stack of 3 tall laundry posts we had dug up out of the yard from the house up north we're selling -- so we decided to use one of those, which gives us a nice T-brace arm from which we can hang Chris's special strawberry planter out of the reach of deer!  His strawberry planter was a birthday present so he won't have to spend too many back-breaking hours weeding another strawberry patch and end up in months of physical therapy (like he did last year -- that was bad news!).

Once we had all our various types of posts installed, it was very quick and easy to just unroll the deer fencing and use zip ties to attach it to the posts.





We used the house as our 4th wall of our fence, and tied a garden shed into one of the sides to cut down the amount of materials we needed.  We just used screws and hooked the deer netting over them for a slightly annoying but simple access point in case we find we want more than one entrance.

Fencing complete!

Old pegboard frame finds new life as a gate!

The only tricky part was figuring out our primary gate.  Back in 2012, we had seen a couple of metal frames in the yard at Community Forklift, identical to each other except that one had a pegboard attached to it.  At the time, Bea had really wanted a pegboard hung in the workshop to keep track of all our tools, so we'd bought a piece earlier that year but hadn't figured out a frame for it yet to attach to our workbench.  Since the pegboard/frame was sitting out in the yard and had a lot of water damage, Bea paid $5 for the frame that came without the pegboard attached so we could attach the one we already owned.  Anyway, it turned out that whoever had donated those to the warehouse must have had some additional hardware to attach the pegboard because we never figured out how they went together, but eventually moved both pieces here still hanging out uselessly near our workbench, where they continued to sit until we were prepping for our housewarming and Bea said “enough is enough, let's just hang this pegboard on the blank wall here."  We got some 1x4s and Chris hung it up beautifully, no frame needed!

So now we had this extra metal frame and Bea said “now what do we do with this?" and as a joke, Chris said “it could be our garden gate" and Bea took him seriously -- this is how most things in our marriage happen, actually starting with our getting married at a carousel.  What Chris proposes as a wacky & outlandish out-of-nowhere idea somehow becomes reality with a little finagling & a lot of stubbornness!

Sledgehammer made it work perfectly!

Notched the frame to fit the bolt

Bea bought a chainlink gate hinge kit for $15 that was made to fit with a professional chainlink gate (which would cost about $70, too much).  Bea said, “I think this'll work great."  Chris said dubiously, “You mean fitting a square frame in a round bracket, again?"  Bea made a couple triangular marks with a sharpie and said, “just use a sawzall to notch the rib here and here."  Chris did, and it made the pegboard frame that had been slightly too wide fit perfectly through the bracket!  He got everything attached firmly enough with an extra long bolt & oversized washers, plus a little coaxing from a sledgehammer to bend the bracket.  The final step was the latch which also needed some “modifications" but now works perfectly to make the garden easy to access by humans but impossible (we hope) for deer!

Area fenced in:  50' x 45'
Total cost for fence:  $66
Total time to install fence:  18 person-hours

Chris takes a well-deserved break, content knowing
that no deer can get to him inside our new fence!

In theory, this is a semi-temporary fence, although we do hope it'll last at least a couple of seasons.  We'll update as we figure out how well it works -- or doesn't!